Document Type : Original Article
Authors
1 PhD Student, Department of Philosophy, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran.
2 Associate Professor, Department of Philosophy, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
According to the standard reading of Wittgenstein, there are two philosophical periods in his life. The earlier Wittgenstein, whose main work is the Tractatus, believes in a fixed essence of language and linguistic propositions. Therefore, other sentences, such as mythical or ritual sentences are meaningless and have no corresponding proposition. The later Wittgenstein, with his Philosophical Investigations, denying his earlier thesis, recognizes various language games. So, there is a place for mythical language games, though mythical sentences are not true. However, this article argues that we should also consider a third Wittgenstein based on his ideas on myth and ritual in his unfinished book On Certainty. According to this third Wittgenstein, firstly, the language game of science doesn’t have the cognitive privilege over other language games, and second, we can talk about the truth and falsity of mythical and ritual propositions. This leads to a pluralism about truth.
Keywords
Main Subjects
Addis, Mark (2001) “D. Z. Phillips’ Fideism in Wittgenstein’s Mirror”, Wittgenstein and Philosophy of Religion, ed. by Robert L. Arrington & Mark Addis, Routledge, pp. 85-100.##
Anscombe, G. E. M. & Von Wright, G. H. (1972) “Preface”, On Certainty, by Ludwig Wittgenstein, Harper Perennial. ##
Bailey, Alan (2001) “Wittgenstein and the interpretation of religious discourse”, Wittgenstein and Philosophy of Religion, ed. by Robert L. Arrington & Mark Addis, Routledge, pp. 119-136.##
Biletzki, Anat (2003) (Over) Interpreting Wittgenstein, Springer.##
Bouchard, Gérard (2017) Social Myths and Collective Imaginaries, University of Toronto Press.##
Bouveresse, Jacques (1995) Wittgenstein Reads Freud, Princeton University Press.##
Brenner, William H. (2001) “Creation, Causality, and freedom of the will”, Wittgenstein and Philosophy of Religion, ed. by Robert L. Arrington & Mark Addis, Routledge, pp. 51-65.##
Cioffi, Frank (1998) Wittgenstein on Freud and Frazer, Cambridge: CUP.##
Clack, Brian R. (1999) Wittgenstein, Frazer and Religion, Palgrave Macmillan.##
Coliva, Annalisa (2017) “Rituals, Philosophy, Science, and Progress: Wittgenstein on Frazer”, Wittgenstein and Scientism, ed. by Jonathan Beale & Ian James Kidd, Routledge, pp. 39-58.##
Cooper, David E. (2017) “Superstition, Science, and Life”, Wittgenstein and Scientism, ed. by Jonathan Beale & Ian James Kidd, Routledge, pp. 28-38##
Cottingham, John (2009) “Lessons of Life: Wittgenstein, Religion, and Analytic Philosophy”, Wittgenstein and Analytic Philosophy, Essays for P. M. S. Hacker, ed. by Hans-Johann Glock & John Hyman, OUP, pp. 203-227.##
Cruickshank, Justin (2002) Realism and Sociology, Routledge.##
Das, Veena (2018) “Of Mistakes, Errors, and Superstition”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 155-180.##
Doty, William G. (2000) Mythography, the Study of Myths and Rituals, University of Alabama Press.##
Floyd, Juliet (2007) “Wittgenstein and the Inexpressible”, Wittgenstein and the Moral Life, ed. by Alice Crary, MIT Press, pp. 177-234.##
Gerhart, Mary & Russell, Allen M. (200) “Myth and Public Science”, Thinking Trough Myths; Philosophical Perspectives, ed. by Kevin Schilbrack, Routledge, pp. 191-206.##
Glock, Hans Johann (1996) A Wittgenstein Dictionary, Blackwell.##
Gyemant, Maria (2015) “Objects or Intentional Objects”, Objects and Pseudo-Objects; Ontological Deserts and Jungles from Brentano to Carnap, ed. by Herbert Hochberg, Rafael Hüntelmann, Christian Kanzian, Richard Schantz & Erwin Tegtmeier, De Gruyter, pp. 85-99.##
Hatab, Lawrence J. (1990) Myth and Philosophy, Open Court.##
Hatab, Lawrence J. (1991) “Heidegger and Myth: A Loop in the History of Being”, Journal of the British Society for Phenomenology, vol. 22, no. 2, pp. 45-64.##
Helm, Paul (2001) “Wittgensteinian Religion and ‘Reformed’ Epistemology”, Wittgenstein and Philosophy of Religion, ed. by Robert L. Arrington & Mark Addis, Routledge, pp. 101-118.##
Hyman, John (2001) “The Gospel according to Wittgenstein”, Wittgenstein and Philosophy of Religion, ed. by Robert L. Arrington & Mark Addis, Routledge, pp.1-11.##
James, Wendy (2018) “Wittgenstein Exercise”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 117-136.##
Kober, Michael (2006) “Wittgenstein and Religion”, Deepening Our Understanding of Wittgenstein, ed. by Michael Kober, Rodopi, pp. 87-116##
Kober, Michael (2017) “Certainties of a World Picture: The Epistemological Investigations of On Certainty”, The Cambridge Companion to Wittgenstein, ed. by Hans Sluga & David G. Stern, CUP, pp. 441-478##
Kwon, Heonik (2018) “Wittgenstein’s Spirit, Frazer’s Ghost”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 87-96.##
Lambek, Michael (2018) “Remarks on Wittgenstein’s Remarks on Frazer’s Golden Bough: Ritual in the Practice of Life”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 181-198##
Laugier, Sandra (2018) “On an Anthropological Tone in Philosophy”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 207-226.##
Malcolm, Norman (1997) Wittgenstein, a Religious Point of View, Routledge.##
Myhre, Knut Christian (2018) “Deep Pragmatism”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 97-116##
Needham, Rodney (2018) “Remarks on Wittgenstein and Ritual”, in The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 227-250.##
Palmie, Stephan (2018) “Translation is Not Explanation: Remarks on the Intellectual History and Context of Wittgenstein’s Remarks on Frazer”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 1-28.##
Pleasants, Nigel (1999) Wittgenstein and the Idea of a Critical Social Theory, Routledge.##
Puett, Michael (2018) “Wittgenstein on Frazer”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 137-154.##
Reed, Rupert (2012) Wittgenstein among the Sciences, Ashgate.##
Rhees, Rush (2018) “Introductory Note on Wittgenstein's Remarks on Frazer”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 29-30##
Russell, Bertrand (1921) “Introduction”, Tractatus, Logico-philosophicus, Routledge, pp. ix-xxv.##
Schilbrack, Kevin (200) “Introduction: on the use of philosophy in the study of myths”, Thinking Trough Myths, Philosophical Perspectives, ed. by Kevin Schilbrack, Routledge, pp. 1-17.##
Schulte, Joachim (2005) “Within a System”, Readings of Wittgenstein’s On Certainty, ed. by Danièle Moyal-Sharrock & William H. Brenner, Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 59-75.##
Severi, Carlo (2018) “On Wittgenstein’s Remarks on Frazer’s Golden Bough”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 77-86.##
Sluga, Hans (2017) “Time and History in Wittgenstein”, The Cambridge Companion to Wittgenstein, ed. by Hans Sluga & David Stern, Cambridge University Press, pp. 417-440.##
Steuer, Daniel (2013) “Wittgenstein and Goethe: Getting Rid of ‘Sorge’”, Wittgenstein Reading, ed. by Sascha Bru, Wolfgang Huemer & Daniel Steuer, De Gruyter, pp. 115-136##
Taussig, Michael (2018) “Explanation as a Kind of Magic”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 199-206.##
Vasiliou, Iakovos (2001) “Wittgenstein, Religious Belief, and On Certainty”, Wittgenstein and Philosophy of Religion, ed. by Robert L. Arrington & Mark Addis, Routledge, pp. 29-50.##
Winch, Peter (1964) “Understanding Primitive Society”, American Philosophical Quarterly, vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 307-324.##
Winch, Peter (1997) “Discussion of Malcolm’s Essay”, Wittgenstein, A Religious Point of View, by Norman Malcolm, Routledge, pp. 95-136.##
Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1921) Tractatus, Logico-philosophicus, Routledge.##
Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1948) Philosophical Investigations, Basil Blackwell.##
Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1972) On Certainty, Basil Blackwell.##
Wittgenstein, Ludwig (2018a) “Remarks on Frazer's the Golden Bough; First Notes”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 29-48##
Wittgenstein, Ludwig (2018b) “Remarks on Frazer's the Golden Bough; Second Notes”, The Mythology in Our Language, ed. by Giovanni da Col & Stephan Palmié, Chicago: HAU Books, pp. 48-76.##
)